IdentityForce: The Best Alternatives and Competitors in 2023

Lauren Sakiyama
Brandon King
Last Updated November 13, 2023

Considering IdentityForce for identity protection? 

I don’t blame you. It’s a good service with lots of features. But after testing several of its competitors, there are better IdentityForce alternatives available. 

Aura is my top pick because it offers all of IdentityForce’s strengths (like accurate monitoring and 24/7/365 customer service) and then adds to them with many digital security features and more flexible family plans. 

Plus, Aura does this at a better price pointwhen you use our OFF discount code, Aura becomes one of the most affordable services available.

IdentityForce Alternatives Price Comparison



Customer Support

Promo Code

  • $9/month 

Aura only offers one plan but offers the same benefits as Identity Guard's Ultra plan

Aura wins with their US-based 24/7 support

Identity Guard
  • $5/mo Value Plan

  • $11.99/mo Total Plan

  • $17.99/mo Ultra Plan

Great US-based customer support but needs 24/7 hours of operation

  • $7.5/mo Standard Plan

  • $15/mo Advantage Plan

  • $20/mo Ultimate Plus Plan

LifeLock promises US based experts but when we tested this, our experience was terrible

Experian IdentityWorks
  • Free/mo Basic

  • $24.99/mo Premium


Hours of Operation: Monday-Saturday from 7 a.m. to 8 p.m

Allstate Identity Theft Protection
  • $9.99/mo Essentials Plan

  • $17.99/mo Premier Plan

US-based 24/7 support

Home Security Heroes independently tests and reviews every product. We may earn a commission when you buy through our links. Read more here.

Top 5 IdentityForce Alternatives Of November 2023

  1. Aura Identity Theft Protection
  2. Identity Guard Identity Theft Protection
  3. Norton LifeLock
  4. Experian IdentityWorks
  5. Allstate Identity Protection

So, while IdentityForce is a good identity protection service, you can do better.  If you’re thinking about switching, read on. I have five alternatives that will make you rethink IdentityForce.

1. Aura Identity Theft Protection

Aura Logo


  • Award-winning identity theft and credit monitoring.
  • 24/7/365 threat resolution services.
  • More flexible family plans with increasing identity theft insurance coverage.
  • Full suite of digital security extras, including comprehensive parental controls.


  • The user interface could be better.

How It Compares 

Aura is my top pick for identity protection because it offers everything you could possibly want at an unbelievable price point. 

Let’s start with the basics. 

Aura excels at the bread and butter of identity protection – monitoring. When I tested it, Aura delivered two dark web alerts in a matter of minutes. It also found ten places where my password was compromised. 

Having accurate and timely alerts means you can fix vulnerabilities and potentially prevent a thief from stealing your hard-earned assets. 

Aura’s monitoring is also comprehensive. It includes everything from SSN monitoring to investment account monitoring. It even goes a step further than IdentityForce by including home and auto title monitoring. 

On top of this, Aura includes a three-bureau credit monitoring standard with all of its plans. You don’t have to pay extra for it like you do with IdentityForce. And, though Aura doesn’t have the nifty credit simulator tools, its credit functions are arguably more useful

With Aura, you get a toggle switch that you can use to lock and unlock your Experian credit. You also have the ability to freeze your child’s credit from your dashboard with their guided freeze services.  

Moving onto the identity restoration side of things…

Aura’s identity restoration services are just as good as IdentityForce’s, giving you 24/7/365 access to a team of threat resolution experts with an average of seven years of industry experience between them. 

And Aura’s theft insurance outshines IdentityForce’s policy by a longshot. With Aura, your identity theft insurance coverage increases by $1 million with each adult you add to the plan. Family plans can include up to five adults, giving you up to $5 million in coverage. 

That’s yet another feather in Aura’s cap – flexible family plans. Unlike IdentityForce, Aura allows you to include adult children, aging parents, and anyone else you need to protect in your family plan. 

Aura also includes far more for families than IdentityForce. If you have young children, you’ll love Aura’s parental control suite, which includes safe gaming. 

The safe gaming service monitors interactions between gamers on over 200 popular games, watching for signs of bullying, grooming, harassment, and racism. This way, parents can step in if there’s a problem.   

You’ll still love Aura’s additional security tools if you have older children or don’t have children at all. These include a VPN, antivirus software, and incredible extras like a family vault, which lets you securely share passwords and files between you and others on your plan. 

aura tech

Aura also includes data broker removal, anti-track and ad blocker services, and spam call protection. 

Best of all, Aura does this at a price that’s lower than IdentityForce. When you use our discount code, you’ll pay significantly less for way more services than IdentityForce includes.  

Aura’s only flaw is in its interface. It’s not my favorite, but it’s certainly usable. And really, IdentityForce’s interface isn’t that great, either.

Related Articles:

2. Identity Guard Identity Theft Protection

identity guard logo


  • Accurate monitoring.
  • Great threat resolution team.
  • Insurance increases with each adult on the plan. 
  • Inexpensive, no-frills plan available.


  • Identity restoration services are only available with a top-tier plan. 
  • Few extra features.

How It Compares 

Identity Guard is Aura’s predecessor. So, it offers many of Aura’s features – including accurate monitoring, top-notch threat resolution experts, and insurance that increases with each adult on the plan. This makes it a great alternative to IdentityForce. 

But Identity Guard is missing a few key things, too. 

For one, you only get white-glove identity restoration services with Identity Guard’s top-tier plan, which is relatively expensive. And Identity Guard doesn’t include many extra features that Aura and even IdentityForce offer. There’s no VPN, for example. And there are no features to help protect children online. 

I can’t recommend Identity Guard as a good alternative to IdentityForce for most people. There’s only one exception…

Identity Guard has a very inexpensive, no-frills “Value” plan. 

This service only includes basic identity monitoring and theft insurance. It doesn’t include help with identity restoration if you become a victim of theft, nor does it include specialized monitoring like an investment account and home title monitoring.

But it might be worth looking at if you want high-quality identity protection and have a very tight budget.


3. Norton LifeLock

Norton LifeLock logo


  • Comes with many online security features.
  • Amazing insurance coverage with a top-tier plan.


  • Poor customer service. 
  • Slow and inaccurate monitoring.
  • Price increase upon renewal.

How It Compares 

It’s tempting to think that LifeLock is the best alternative to IdentityForce. It’s certainly the most well-known, and when you see its lengthy list of features, you might be convinced that it’s the best identity protection service. But, after testing LifeLock, I can’t recommend it to most. 

Here’s why…

LifeLock isn’t as accurate as IdentityForce. In testing, it only came up with one dark web alert. The second “alert” it populated wasn’t an alert at all – it was notifying me that it’d found my home title and would start to monitor it. 

I found it a little annoying that this showed up as an alert and a little concerning that it took close to a week to find my home title to monitor. Public records should be pretty easy to locate. 

LifeLock Alerts

But LifeLock’s inadequacies don’t end there. Though the service offers 24/7 access to its threat resolution team, getting a hold of their customer service is quite the feat. LifeLock does everything possible to direct you to self-help articles rather than give you their support team’s number. 

And LifeLock isn’t straightforward with its pricing. Prices that seem comparable to IdentityForce jump up upon renewal. 

That said, if cost isn’t a concern for you, LifeLock’s top plan might be a good alternative to IdentityForce. This is mainly because it comes with a massive amount of insurance coverage – $3 million per adult and over $1 million for each child on the plan. 

It also includes several security features, like a VPN and Norton’s antivirus software. And family plans come with a thorough parental control suite.

Related: IdentityForce vs LifeLock: Which is the Best?

4. Experian IdentityWorks

Experian identityWorks


  • Top-notch credit monitoring.
  • Free plan available.


  • Paid plans are overpriced.
  • Inaccurate monitoring.

How It Compares 

One of my major gripes with IdentityForce is that it charges significantly more for its credit monitoring tools. If you’re paying for IdentityForce to get its credit monitoring capabilities, consider looking at something like Experian IdentityWorks instead. 

Experian IdentityWorks offers a free plan with a complimentary dark web scan and credit monitoring. It doesn’t include the fancy credit simulation and tracking tools, but it does give you access to Experian Boost.

Experian Boost can improve your credit score by allowing you to apply bills you already pay (like your utility bills, your Netflix subscription, and others) to your credit report. 

Because it’s free, I’d recommend signing up for Experian Identitytworks alongside another identity protection tool

But I wouldn’t recommend using IdentityWorks’ paid plans. They’re overpriced for what they offer and need to be more accurate. In testing, they took several days to turn up a single threat on my information.

The paid IdentityWorks plans also fail to include any extra online security features. There’s no VPN or antivirus software. They don’t even offer a password manager. Yet, their price is much higher than other services (like Aura) that include all of these things.

Read in-depth comparison of IdentityForce and Experian IdentityWorks.

5. Allstate Identity Protection

allstate logo


  • Amazing fund reimbursement policy
  • Comprehensive monitoring services


  • Inaccurate monitoring

How It Compares 

Allstate Identity Protection rivals LifeLock and Aura in terms of features and comprehensive monitoring – which means it surpasses IdentityForce. 

With Allstate’s top-tier plan, you get all the bells and whistles, including niche monitoring services like investment account monitoring, a full cybersecurity suite, and some of the best fund reimbursement policies I’ve ever seen. 

Allstate will reimburse up to $500 in cash if you lose your wallet. They’ll also reimburse you up to $2 million if you experience home title fraud and will reimburse up to $1 million in stolen investment account funds. 

While all of this sounds fantastic, there’s only one issue with Allstate’s services – its monitoring isn’t accurate. 

allstate dashboard

In testing, it failed to find a single dark web threat. So, though it checks all of the boxes on paper, in practice, it’s not the best service. 

How We Choose The Best Identity Protection Services 

Whether you’re considering an identity protection service for the first time or a longtime IdentityForce user ready for something new, finding the best service isn’t easy. 

It helps if you know what to look for, though. At Home Security Heroes, we pay attention to the following areas first and foremost: 

  • Monitoring. Without comprehensive and accurate monitoring, a service can’t help you proactively protect your identity. Instead, you’re waiting for damage to occur. As a general rule, it’s easier to prevent damage to your identity than it is to fix it, so monitoring that’s both accurate and comprehensive is important.
  • Threat resolution. No identity protection service can guarantee you won’t end up a victim of identity theft. So, a top-notch threat resolution team is crucial. Ideally, they’ll be available 24/7/365 and offer white-glove restoration services. That way, if you lose your identity, you know there’s a team behind you, ready and willing to help.
  • Insurance coverage. Most identity protection plans include $1 million in identity theft insurance. That $1 million is often static, regardless of the number of people on your plan. So, if you include your spouse or adult children, the $1 million remains the same.

    The best identity protection companies increase their insurance coverage for each adult on the plan. Aura and Identity Guard, for example, increase insurance by $1 million for each adult and allow for up to five adults on a family plan.
  • Added features. Though they’re not crucial, additional security and privacy features are nice to have with an identity protection service. Many of the best services offer things like VPNs, antivirus software, and password managers. Some even include parental control features, making them one-stop-shops for your digital protection needs.
  • Cost. Low cost isn’t always better, but your identity protection service needs to fit your budget. And even if your budget is on the larger side, you don’t want to overpay for services. The best identity protection companies offer a lot of features at a very affordable rate.   

Final Thoughts: Is Identity Force legit?

IdentityForce isn’t a bad identity protection service. It has a lot to offer, but it also falls short in several areas. And its price point isn’t exactly cheap. 

There are better services available at better price points. 

Aura, for example, offers monitoring that’s more comprehensive and just as accurate. It comes with an expert threat resolution team, insurance coverage that increases with every adult on your plan, and all the added features you could possibly want, including a VPN, family password and file fault, data broker removal services, and more. 

And Aura does all of this at a much lower price point. When you use our discount code, you lock in an extra low rate for life.

So, if you were thinking of signing up for IdentityForce – don’t. And if you already have, it’s time to cancel. There are much better identity protection services out there.

Related Article: IdentityForce – An In-Depth Review